Quantcast
MarkLives.com

MarkLives.com

Independent industry news for marketing, advertising & media execs

  • Home
  • Sections
    • Adland
    • #CoronavirusSA
    • Media
    • Marketing
    • S’HOT
    • Tech
    • Archive
  • Columns
    • #AdChamps – Kyle & Morgan
    • #AgencyLeaders – Most Admired Poll
    • Accountant in Adland – Siwe Lawrence
    • Big Q – MarkLives Panel
    • Campaigns – MarkLives
    • Circulation Data – ABC Analysis
    • Clicks ‘n Tricks – Charlie Stewart
    • #CoronavirusSA – Special Section
    • Curiosity – Marguerite Coetzee
    • #CustomerFirst – Craig Hannabus
    • Dear Radio – Paulo Dias
    • Extracts — Books & research
    • Fair Exchange – Erna George
    • Hard Relate – David Alves
    • Herding Words – Wendy Shepherd
    • Hermaneutics – Herman Manson
    • Masterclass Notes – Johanna McDowell
    • Media Redefined – Martin MacGregor
    • Mission – Tom Fels
    • Motive – By Invitation Only
    • #NotSoOrdinary – Taazima Kala-Essack
    • Press Pass – Carey Finn
    • Q5 – Carey Finn
    • SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
    • #TheInterlocker – Emma King
    • The Martini Shot – Bobby Amm
    • The Power Report – Megan Power
    • The Suit – Jason Harrison
    • Thinking B2B – Warren Moss
    • #Transformers Transform 2020
    • Watched – Richard Lord
    • #WritersBlock – Tiffany Markman
    • WTF?! – Leigh Tayler
    • Young, Gifted & Killing It – Veli Ngubane
    • Zeitgeist of Now – Jason Stewart
  • Find an Agency
    • Shortlist & Compare Agencies
    • List your Agency
    • List as Agency Supplier/Service
    • Register as a Marketer
    • Company News Feed
    • Upgrade to Ramify Premium
    • RamifyPRO
    • Add Premium to Cart
  • Data
    • Agency Revenue Rankings 2019
    • Agency Salary Survey
    • Biggest SA consumer magazines
    • Biggest newspapers in SA
    • The 50 most-valuable brands in SA
    • Top 50 SA advertisers 2016
    • SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
  • Careers
    • Advertising
    • Digital
    • Marketing
    • Media
    • Public Relations
    • View All
  • About
    • About & Contact
    • Advertise
    • Business supporters
    • Privacy Policy
    • Readership
    • Submissions
  • Partners
    • Brands & Branding
    • Brands & Branding – Profiles
    • Retailing Africa
    • Retailer/Supplier profiles
    • Ramify.biz
Fair Exchange – Erna George
leadership-management-professional courtesy of Pixabay

Fair Exchange: Learning through the ranks for effective leadership

  •   9 Oct 2019
  •   0
Share

by Erna George (@edgeo23) Must a chief marketing officer or specialist director start in the junior ranks of brand management or may they join from general business, strategy or other communication fields?

When I last wrote about the balance between experience and a novel and newer perspective, I concluded that the “focus must be on balancing the effect of practised knowhow and proficiency with relevance and fresh thinking”. This stimulated a debate among a few colleagues about what this means for senior leadership within marketing.  The opinions were multiple and fairly split but, when I asked for the ‘why’ behind the sentiment, shifting opinions and strong general themes became apparent. After the general chat, I posed this question in depth to about 15 people across the various levels within marketing, from senior HR parties to senior GM.

Minority view

The minority view was that time through the ranks isn’t a prerequisite.

Thinking started along the lines of it may work if “you are a strategic person and have the expertise and experience (in any field of marketing)”. Given the focus of a senior director’s role is on setting the vision and providing strategic perspective on branding, a few seemed comfortable that this is possible. A key benefit cited was that, with this strategic focus, it would be easier to avoid the person delving into the detailed inner workings of campaigns or projects which disempowers (the word used was “suffocates”) junior team members. It’s tempting to fall back into a comfort zone, with the result that one never allows team members to push boundaries, explore fresh options or lead the thinking.

What was interesting as conversations unfolded is that about half that started backtracking on their initial views. The provisos ranged from:

  1. Perhaps they wouldn’t have been a brand or marketing manager but it would be highly beneficial to have had at least more junior roles to ensure understanding of the dynamics, the processes and progression through the levels.
    (We did discuss that this would constitute learning through the ranks!)
  2. Some thought it was idealistic to expect hands-on experience; exposure could be driven from in-depth research on the tasks and shape of junior positions or to immerse themselves with the teams across various aspects of the roles to understand critical focal points, challenges and opportunities. Listening would be the most-important requirement in this journey. So, with a sound strategic background within a different field (eg a strategist from an agency), one can apply thinking from the past but needs be open to learning about ‘the other side’ to build the ability to navigate and lead on elements such as commercial, innovation, sales focus etc.

Context

Some weren’t keen on a definite yes or no; it was all about the context.

The industry was deemed a critical determining factor. In particular, for FMCG, it was felt that it was a distinct advantage, if not requirement, to have had junior experience to avoid lofty principles being applied in time-pressured and fairly structured environments. For many in this group, it wasn’t a blanket aye or nay and, beyond the qualifier of industry, the following were vital:

  1. A passion for the field beyond the boardroom or strategy — a willingness to walk the walk.
    Leaders without experience in marketing junior positions, or new to the industry of the business, were expected to participate in a cross-section of interactions to immerse themselves in the value chain the marketing team is working within. Why? So that they understood where to break rules and where toeing the line is more beneficial and how to judge between these.
    (Doesn’t this sound familiar from the first group’s expectation of exposure or immersing in the value chain their team operate within?)
  2. The other area, where concession wasn’t an option, was a curiosity and commitment to be consumer-led.

Overall, it was interesting to listen to the hemming and hawing, and the conclusion from this group was indeed a level of discomfort as, while they didn’t want to be definite, many struggled to find examples of where they have seen people without direct exposure succeed in the long-term or without fairly tough and steep learning curves.

Majority view

For the majority, it was a resounding no and the critical aspect was around leadership principles.

For these people, it wasn’t to say that the person wouldn’t be able to do the job overall, as many skills are transferable, especially in the corporate world. The key consideration was how could one provide guidance and make optimal decisions without specific knowledge and skills or without having experienced that environment themselves and having executed the daily tasks of a marketing professional? This belief rests within the perspective that are certain skills and approaches one learns through trial, and this is important to manage when empowering others.

The comparison was made to an HR director, with only general management experience, trying to deal with an angry or militant union; he or she is likely to fair better with some experience under their belt. Having built muscle around actual trial would make application easier and more pertinent.

  1. The incumbent must have an appreciation for the context marketers are operating in to be an effective leader. Having an understanding of the work and requirements from his/her team helps with clear output expectations, realistic timings and relevant problem-solving guidance. In addition, this group felt that actual time in marketing teams allows a leader to credibly cut through the bull quickly so the real opportunity won’t be missed.
  2. The biggest areas of concern were around effective leadership:
    1. Empathy for the team having walked the walk
    2. Delivering or judging talent progression journeys, and
    3. Rallying the team with gravitas

Most were adamant that their history with leaders who had no direct experience resulted in a limited ability to provide the best support and guidance or offer clarity in directing activities. Theoretical views aren’t sufficient. Rallying behind a way of working and vision requires more than general views and strong magnetism.

Strong similarities

While there were some subtle differences across the three groups, when it comes to senior leadership roles in specialist areas, there were strong similarities in opinions:

  1. While experience in the field is preferred, without this the next best solution is to immerse oneself in the industry and specific inner workings of the marketing department in the first 10-days plan; this enhances the planning and execution of strategies and workings of the team for progression planning
  2. Listening is critical in this journey — looking for the nuances allows the person to have a critical eye to optimise what’s working and relevantly fix what needs work but also to effectively guide, support and empower the team
  3. Keep the consumer at the heart always (hopefully the easiest to deliver on)

What was more interesting is that there were few strong features that could be distinguished between each group, except that the resounding “no” group was made up of the most junior (seeking strong leadership and guidance) and the most senior, in addition to most of the cross-functional team views (offering some experience beyond the marketer perspective). A bigger sample is definitely required.

Conclusion

Overall, it was an interesting conversation with areas of discomfort for many, perhaps indicating an opportunity to have greater clarification and gravitas in the articulation of the responsibilities and career trajectory for marketers. But, for now, the conclusion is that specialist marketing director roles require insight and experience on specific skills or abilities within the industry and/or on the client-side; this prior experience, in conjunction with curiosity, would facilitate an ability to develop strong future-growth thinking.

See also

  • Fair Exchange: Experienced vs newer models — both have merit

 

Erna GeorgeAfter starting at Unilever in a classical marketing role, Erna George (@edgeo23) explored the agency side of life, first as a partner at Fountainhead Design, followed by the manic and inspiring world of consultancy at Added Value. She has returned to client-side, leading the marketing team in the Cereals, Accompaniments & Baking Division at Pioneer Foods. Her monthly “Fair Exchange” column on MarkLives concerns business relationships and partnerships in marketing and brandland.

— Sign up now for the MarkLives newsletter, including Ramify.biz headlines, emailed every Monday, Wednesday and Friday!

Share

Columns

  • #AdChamps – Kyle de Waal & Morgan Botha
    #AdChamps – Kyle de Waal & Morgan Botha
  • #AgencyLeaders – Most Admired Poll
    #AgencyLeaders – Most Admired Poll
  • #CoronavirusSA – Special Section
    #CoronavirusSA – Special Section
  • #CustomerFirst – Craig Hannabus
    #CustomerFirst – Craig Hannabus
  • #NotSoOrdinary – Taazima Kala-Essack
    #NotSoOrdinary – Taazima Kala-Essack
  • #TheInterlocker – Emma King
    #TheInterlocker – Emma King
  • #Transformers Transform 2020
    #Transformers Transform 2020
  • #WritersBlock – Tiffany Markman
    #WritersBlock – Tiffany Markman
  • An Accountant in Adland – Siwe Lawrence
    An Accountant in Adland – Siwe Lawrence
  • Big Q – MarkLives Panel
    Big Q – MarkLives Panel
  • Big Reads on MarkLives
    Big Reads on MarkLives
  • By Invitation Only – Motive
    By Invitation Only – Motive
  • Campaigns – MarkLives
    Campaigns – MarkLives
  • Circulation Data – ABC Analysis
    Circulation Data – ABC Analysis
  • Clicks ’n Tricks – Charlie Stewart
    Clicks ’n Tricks – Charlie Stewart
  • Curiosity – Marguerite Coetzee
    Curiosity – Marguerite Coetzee
  • Dear Radio – Paulo Dias
    Dear Radio – Paulo Dias
  • Extracts — Books & Research
    Extracts — Books & Research
  • Fair Exchange – Erna George
    Fair Exchange – Erna George
  • Hard Relate – David Alves
    Hard Relate – David Alves
  • Herding Words – Wendy Shepherd
    Herding Words – Wendy Shepherd
  • Hermaneutics – Herman Manson
    Hermaneutics – Herman Manson
  • Masterclass Notes – Johanna McDowell
    Masterclass Notes – Johanna McDowell
  • Media Redefined – Martin MacGregor
    Media Redefined – Martin MacGregor
  • Mission – Tom Fels
    Mission – Tom Fels
  • Press Pass – Carey Finn
    Press Pass – Carey Finn
  • Q5 – Carey Finn
    Q5 – Carey Finn
  • SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
    SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
  • Spotlight – MarkLives
    Spotlight – MarkLives
  • The Martini Shot – Bobby Amm
    The Martini Shot – Bobby Amm
  • The Power Report – Megan Power
    The Power Report – Megan Power
  • The Suit – Jason Harrison
    The Suit – Jason Harrison
  • Thinking B2B – Warren Moss
    Thinking B2B – Warren Moss
  • Watched – Richard Lord
    Watched – Richard Lord
  • WTF?! – Leigh Tayler
    WTF?! – Leigh Tayler
  • Young, Gifted & Killing It – Veli Ngubane
    Young, Gifted & Killing It – Veli Ngubane
  • Zeitgeist of Now – Jason Stewart
    Zeitgeist of Now – Jason Stewart
  • View All
  • Mid-Weight Brand Manager: Global South African Brand
    15 Jan 2021
  • Senior Graphic Designer: Super TTL Ad Agency
    14 Jan 2021
  • Email Marketing Strategist – Remote for US company
    13 Jan 2021
  • PR, Partnerships & Influencer Manager: International Brand
    13 Jan 2021
  • Growth Marketer & Paid Acquisition Specialist: Global Brand
    13 Jan 2021
  • Amazon Specialist: Global Hearing Protection Brand
    13 Jan 2021
  • Creative Director: In House Agency
    13 Jan 2021
  • Brand Manager: Leading Décor Brand: In-House
    12 Jan 2021
  • Senior Account Manager: 6-Month Contract
    12 Jan 2021
  • Motion Graphic Designer
    7 Jan 2021
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply.

    No comments yet.

    Related News

    #CoronavirusSA, Columns, Fair Exchange – Erna George, Featured, Marketing marketing-strategies by Gerd Altmann courtesy of Pixabay

    Fair Exchange: Covid-19 & marketing language

    23 Sep 2020
    Columns, Fair Exchange – Erna George, Featured, Marketing board-slate-blackboard-font courtesy of Pixabay

    Fair Exchange: Balanced bravery for growing brands

    24 Jul 2020
    Columns, Fair Exchange – Erna George, Featured, Marketing Image courtesy of Pixabay

    Fair Exchange: Diversity in marketing critical for growth, positive outcomes

    17 Jun 2020
    Facebook
    Like us on Facebook
    Twitter
    Follow us on Twitter
    Google Plus
    Add us on Google Plus
    YouTube
    Join us on YouTube
    Pinterest
    Follow us on Pinterest
    Subscribe Newsletter

    Get our round-up of top ad and media industry news every Monday and Thursday.

    Online CPD Courses Psychology Online CPD Courses Marketing analytics software Marketing analytics software for small business Business management software Business accounting software Gearbox repair company Makeup artist