Quantcast
MarkLives.com

MarkLives.com

Independent industry news for marketing, advertising & media execs

  • Home
  • Sections
    • Adland
    • #CoronavirusSA
    • Media
    • Marketing
    • S’HOT
    • Tech
    • Archive
  • Columns
    • #AdChamps – Kyle & Morgan
    • #AgencyLeaders – Most Admired Poll
    • Accountant in Adland – Siwe Lawrence
    • Big Q – MarkLives Panel
    • Campaigns – MarkLives
    • Circulation Data – ABC Analysis
    • Clicks ‘n Tricks – Charlie Stewart
    • #CoronavirusSA – Special Section
    • Curiosity – Marguerite Coetzee
    • #CustomerFirst – Craig Hannabus
    • Dear Radio – Paulo Dias
    • Extracts — Books & research
    • Fair Exchange – Erna George
    • Hard Relate – David Alves
    • Herding Words – Wendy Shepherd
    • Hermaneutics – Herman Manson
    • Masterclass Notes – Johanna McDowell
    • Media Redefined – Martin MacGregor
    • Mission – Tom Fels
    • Motive – By Invitation Only
    • #NotSoOrdinary – Taazima Kala-Essack
    • Press Pass – Carey Finn
    • Q5 – Carey Finn
    • SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
    • #TheInterlocker – Emma King
    • The Martini Shot – Bobby Amm
    • The Power Report – Megan Power
    • The Suit – Jason Harrison
    • Thinking B2B – Warren Moss
    • #Transformers Transform 2020
    • Watched – Richard Lord
    • #WritersBlock – Tiffany Markman
    • WTF?! – Leigh Tayler
    • Young, Gifted & Killing It – Veli Ngubane
    • Zeitgeist of Now – Jason Stewart
  • Find an Agency
    • Shortlist & Compare Agencies
    • List your Agency
    • List as Agency Supplier/Service
    • Register as a Marketer
    • Company News Feed
    • Upgrade to Ramify Premium
    • RamifyPRO
    • Add Premium to Cart
  • Data
    • Agency Revenue Rankings 2020
    • Agency Salary Survey
    • Biggest SA consumer magazines
    • Biggest newspapers in SA
    • The 50 most-valuable brands in SA
    • Top 50 SA advertisers 2016
    • SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
  • Careers
    • Advertising
    • Digital
    • Marketing
    • Media
    • Public Relations
    • View All
  • About
    • About & Contact
    • Advertise
    • Business supporters
    • Privacy Policy
    • Readership
    • Submissions
  • Partners
    • Brands & Branding
    • Brands & Branding – Profiles
    • Retailing Africa
    • Retailer/Supplier profiles
    • Ramify.biz
Big Q – MarkLives Panel
Ivan Moroke

Big Q: Transformation apartheid plagues SA ad agencies

  •   6 Mar 2017
  •   0
Share

by MarkLives (@marklives) The marketing and advertising industries are transforming. So why are so many black professionals disgruntled with the rate of progress? And is the quality of most of the work specifically directed at a black audiences still sub-par? We emailed a panel of key industry executives for their take. First up is Ivan Moroke of Co-Currency.

Ivan Moroke

Ivan MorokeThe career of Ivan Moroke (@ivanmoroke) has shaped and has been shaped by brands, from running his family shebeen in Atteridgeville (many, many years ago) to starting a marketing consultancy, Co-Currency, 18 months ago. Consciously and unconsciously, his passion for what he does is rooted in the the power of authentic collaboration to create new possibilities. Daily, he is inspired by the three truisms: 1. You can never know the full story… 2. but everything is connected… 3. including the two statements.

On the face of it, South African advertising is transforming itself. Inside today’s ad agencies, you see lots of black faces and brown faces, as well as white. Often, however, transformation is only skin-deep. Go deeper and you encounter subtle forms of transformation apartheid.

Let me explain…

When the old white government became embarrassed by the term “apartheid”, it called the system “separate development” instead — one set of stellar opportunities for whites and a third-rate set of hand-me-down opportunities for blacks. Our ad agencies are not so crass. Many make sincere attempts to provide better opportunities. But, on closer examination, you see the “separate development” ethos in black and white.

The big idea

To understand what’s happening, you have to consider the philosophy and the traditional holy grail of the big idea. All ad agencies tell you the big idea is core competence. This is their preferred creative currency. But what is a big idea?

My definition is an organising creative concept that speaks to the human condition or experience based on a human truth or insight. Here we enter the realm of human truths, and human truths are universal. The setting might be African, American or European, but the core idea is so big it resonates everywhere.

Big ideas — properly executed — do great things for brands (and ad agencies and their creatives). National and international recognition follows. Global celebrations of creativity such as the Cannes Festival salute you. This is the fast track to career success and I applaud every brand, agency and creative team that achieves the big breakthrough.

Now check the pigmentation of the creatives who delivered the big idea. You will see that white executive creative directors, creative directors, copywriters and art directors predominate. Why is this? A key reason is that big campaigns with international relevance are entrusted to white creatives, not blacks. Whites are assumed to be more attuned to international norms.

Separate track

What happens on the wrong side of the international fast track? Solid success may be achieved here, too, but without glamour and global acclaim. This separate track is dedicated to campaigns that have local relevance but don’t pretend to speak to consumers everywhere. These campaigns are often targeted at the township market. If the market is black, then black insights are needed. Therefore, the work goes to black teams.

In practice, we see separate development. Think international scope and global accolades and you use the white pigeonhole. Think black consumers and the township market, and you use the black pigeonhole. To put it crudely, the whites get the French Riviera; the blacks get low-income communities you reach by taxi.

Similar dynamics may also apply in the strategic area.

Apart-ness like this need not be deliberately racist. Separation may also exist at agencies where black executives hold senior positions.

Entrenches a de facto system

However, the use of local and global pigeonholes entrenches a de facto system of separate development. These divisive trends have to be urgently addressed. The starting point is to acknowledge these dangers and admit transformation should be better than this.

Lots of factors are in play, including the complicity between whites driven by self-interest and blacks who are content to ‘sell out’. This is just one aspect of a complex story and the subject for another day…

See also

  • Big Q: Transformation — what you need to know & change — Herman Manson
  • Big Q: Transformation needs buy-in on the demand side — Monalisa Sibongile Zwambila
  • Big Q: Transformation — the proverbial workhorses have bolted — Grant Sithole
  • Big Q: Transformation — clients must take road less travelled — Zibusiso Mkhwanazi
  • Big Q: What we need to achieve true transformation — Masego Motsogi
  • Big Q: Concept of transformation not embraced by our industry — Sbu Sitole
  • Big Q: “Some” transformation is simply not good enough — Ahmed Tilly

 

MarkLives logoLaunched in 2016, “The Big Q” is a regular column on MarkLives in which we ask key industry execs for their thoughts on relevant issues facing the ad industry. If you’d like to be part of our pool of potential panellists, please contact editor Herman Manson via email (2mark at marklives dot com) or Twitter (@marklives). Suggestions for questions are also welcomed.

— Sign up now for the MarkLives email newsletter every Monday and Thursday, now including headlines from the Ramify.biz company newsroom service!

Share

Columns

  • #AdChamps, #AdOfTheWeek & #AdOfTheYear
    #AdChamps, #AdOfTheWeek & #AdOfTheYear
  • #AgencyLeaders – Most Admired Poll
    #AgencyLeaders – Most Admired Poll
  • #CoronavirusSA – Special Section
    #CoronavirusSA – Special Section
  • #CustomerFirst – Craig Hannabus
    #CustomerFirst – Craig Hannabus
  • #NotSoOrdinary – Taazima Kala-Essack
    #NotSoOrdinary – Taazima Kala-Essack
  • #TheInterlocker – Emma King
    #TheInterlocker – Emma King
  • #Transformers Transform 2020
    #Transformers Transform 2020
  • #WritersBlock – Tiffany Markman
    #WritersBlock – Tiffany Markman
  • An Accountant in Adland – Siwe Lawrence
    An Accountant in Adland – Siwe Lawrence
  • Big Q – MarkLives Panel
    Big Q – MarkLives Panel
  • Big Reads on MarkLives
    Big Reads on MarkLives
  • By Invitation Only – Motive
    By Invitation Only – Motive
  • Campaigns – MarkLives
    Campaigns – MarkLives
  • Circulation Data – ABC Analysis
    Circulation Data – ABC Analysis
  • Clicks ’n Tricks – Charlie Stewart
    Clicks ’n Tricks – Charlie Stewart
  • Curiosity – Marguerite Coetzee
    Curiosity – Marguerite Coetzee
  • Dear Radio – Paulo Dias
    Dear Radio – Paulo Dias
  • Extracts — Books & Research
    Extracts — Books & Research
  • Fair Exchange – Erna George
    Fair Exchange – Erna George
  • Hard Relate – David Alves
    Hard Relate – David Alves
  • Herding Words – Wendy Shepherd
    Herding Words – Wendy Shepherd
  • Hermaneutics – Herman Manson
    Hermaneutics – Herman Manson
  • Masterclass Notes – Johanna McDowell
    Masterclass Notes – Johanna McDowell
  • Media Redefined – Martin MacGregor
    Media Redefined – Martin MacGregor
  • Mission – Tom Fels
    Mission – Tom Fels
  • Press Pass – Carey Finn
    Press Pass – Carey Finn
  • Q5 – Carey Finn
    Q5 – Carey Finn
  • SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
    SA TV Ratings – MarkLives
  • Spotlight – MarkLives
    Spotlight – MarkLives
  • The Martini Shot – Bobby Amm
    The Martini Shot – Bobby Amm
  • The Power Report – Megan Power
    The Power Report – Megan Power
  • The Suit – Jason Harrison
    The Suit – Jason Harrison
  • Thinking B2B – Warren Moss
    Thinking B2B – Warren Moss
  • Watched – Richard Lord
    Watched – Richard Lord
  • WTF?! – Leigh Tayler
    WTF?! – Leigh Tayler
  • Young, Gifted & Killing It – Veli Ngubane
    Young, Gifted & Killing It – Veli Ngubane
  • Zeitgeist of Now – Jason Stewart
    Zeitgeist of Now – Jason Stewart
  • View All
  • Lead Generation & Content Marketing Specialist Copywriter
    24 Jun 2022
  • Brand Manager: Retail: Renowned Wine Estate
    24 Jun 2022
  • On Line Content Producer – Reality TV – 3 month gig
    24 Jun 2022
  • Integrated, Copy-Based ECD: Awarded Ad Agency
    24 Jun 2022
  • Copywriter
    20 Jun 2022
  • Digital Executive Creative Director: Hot Ad Agency
    20 Jun 2022
  • PR Communications Manager: Financial Investments
    20 Jun 2022
  • Account Manager
    20 Jun 2022
  • Video Editor
    20 Jun 2022
  • Account/Project Manager: Hot 360°Agency: Contract/Permanent
    14 Jun 2022
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply.

    No comments yet.

    Related News

    #Transformers Transform 2020, Adland, Columns, Featured, Marketing #Transformers Transform 2020 logo with playbook cover

    #TransformersTransform2020: Download the playbook now

    10 Sep 2020
    #CoronavirusSA, #Transformers Transform 2020, Columns, Featured, Marketing #Transformers Transform 2020 logo with Bozoma Saint John

    #Transformers: Change matters. Just do it.

    3 Sep 2020
    #CoronavirusSA, Columns, Featured, Marketing, Mission – Tom Fels MarkLives Mission capitalism vs care slider

    Mission: Conflict sparked between capitalism & care

    1 Sep 2020
    Facebook
    Like us on Facebook
    Twitter
    Follow us on Twitter
    Google Plus
    Add us on Google Plus
    YouTube
    Join us on YouTube
    Pinterest
    Follow us on Pinterest
    Subscribe Newsletter

    Get our round-up of top ad and media industry news every Monday and Thursday.

    Online CPD Courses Psychology Online CPD Courses Marketing analytics software Marketing analytics software for small business Business management software Business accounting software Gearbox repair company Makeup artist